Don’t let the price tag fool you — this guy’s more complex than the Saturday New York Times crossword. Smooth, nutty malt goes toe-to-toe with ripe lemons, peaches and pears, subtle nutmeg spice, cooling ginger and mint, and acacia honey, all sliding into a silky coconut and vanilla ice cream finish. Consider it dessert in a glass (but be sure to hold the jimmies).
Highland Park Magnus
For $40 big ones, you’re looking at a fine sherry cask-aged single malt boasting honey-kissed, lightly toasted bread on nose, stone fruit, vanilla, and smoked wood chips on the palate and a dry, spiced licorice finish. Bonus: It comes encased in an extra slick jet black bottle inspired by distillery founder Magnus Eunson’s Viking bootlegger ancestry. Because when it comes to badass booze lore, nobody beats the Scottish.
Kirkland Signature Highland 18-year-old Sherry Cask Finish
How did Costco brand hooch make it onto this list? Because not only is it delicious, but you’re never, ever (ever) going to find a better deal on a genuine 18-year-old sherry-finished Scotch whiskey. The trade-off, of course, is that they keep the exact distillery of origin a mystery (that and the whole having to get a Costco membership thing). But when it tastes this good — fragrant leather, tree bark, and tobacco followed by figgy pudding, hazelnuts, boozy sherry, and what only can be described as those Christmasy chocolate oranges that break into cute little slices when you smash them — you don’t ask questions.
Dubbed the world’s most-awarded single malt, you really can’t go wrong pouring a dram of this Speyside original. It’s the perfect entry whiskey — great for both selfless gifting and solo guzzling, especially for fans of orchard-fresh pears and apples, oatmeal raisin cookies, warm fruit cobbler, and whipped butterscotch mousse. So yeah, basically everyone.
For those of you turning your noses up at the thought of a blended whiskey right now, save it. Fun fact: It wasn’t so long ago that blends were all the rage and single malts were seen as dusty nursing home fodder. This here blend transforms 20+ Highland malts into layers of lemon curd, banana bread, grapefruit rind, candied fruit, baking spice, and whiffs of smoke. And if that wasn’t enough to sway you, consider that it’s named after Ernest Shackleton, an explorer who toted 25 cases of Mackinlay’s whiskey on his 1907 South Pole expedition. (The guy ended up turning back 97 miles short of victory, but nobody blames the Scotch.)
Johnnie Walker Blenders’ Batch Wine Cask
Any old fool can pick up a bottle of Johnnie Walker but it takes a real whiskey aficionado (aka anyone reading this list) to suss out something as elegant, unique, and — dare we say — ridiculously underpriced, as this wine barrel-aged expression from blender Aimée Gibson. As light and refreshing as a bubbling Highlands brook, it’s all berries and blossoms up front tempered by a hint of tobacco, Heath bar, and crusty bread. It’s excellent for making highballs and convincing certain haters that they do, in fact, like brown liquor.
This mellow peated blend has a silver medal from the 2018 World Whiskey Awards, 90 points from Wine Enthusiast, and 88 points from Whiskey Advocate. And if you’ve got $25 bucks to spare and a penchant for Juicy Fruit gum, plump apricots, orange pekoe, and creme Brule against a pleasant smoky backdrop, it’s also got your name on it, pal.
An easy-drinking, high-scoring Speyside single malt for $25? Sign us up. It doesn’t hurt that its particular combination of dried herbs, lemon, buttery shortbread, and marmalade notes is the spitting image of a proper Scottish high tea service… except for 1,000 times more fun.
Speyburn Bradan Orach
If you ask me, this is hands down the tastiest single malt alone Andrew Jackson can get you. The juice is matured entirely in ex-bourbon casks, with peppery oak, rich vanilla, and toasted nutmeg notes playing yin to the bright lemon and sweet honey’s yang. Apparently, Bradan Orach is Gaelic for “golden salmon,” but don’t worry, we’re pretty sure it’s still vegan.